Translate

Showing posts with label Apostle Thomas. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Apostle Thomas. Show all posts

Wednesday, April 03, 2024

From Doubt to Faith


The Incredulity of Saint Thomas by Caravaggio, c. 1602

The Transformative Journey of Thomas


In the gospel of John, we encounter the story of Thomas, often remembered as "Doubting Thomas." His journey from skepticism to profound faith serves as a timeless reminder of the transformative power of encountering Jesus.


Despite witnessing the miracles and teachings of Jesus alongside his disciples, Thomas struggled to believe in the resurrection. When his companions joyously proclaimed encountering the risen Lord, Thomas remained skeptical, demanding tangible proof. It's a relatable human response—doubt often creeps in when faced with the miraculous.


Yet, Jesus, in His infinite grace and compassion, didn't cast Thomas aside for his doubt. Instead, He met Thomas in his skepticism, offering not condemnation but an invitation to deeper faith. When Jesus appeared to the disciples again, He specifically addressed Thomas, inviting him to touch His wounds, to see and believe.


In that moment of encounter, doubt gave way to awe-inspiring faith. As Thomas beheld the scars of Jesus' crucifixion, he uttered the profound confession, "My Lord and my God!" In that declaration, Thomas not only acknowledged Jesus' resurrection but also His divine identity.


Thomas' journey teaches us that doubt doesn't disqualify us from encountering Jesus; rather, it serves as a catalyst for deeper faith. Jesus invites us, like Thomas, to bring our doubts and skepticism to Him, knowing that He meets us where we are and leads us into profound revelation.


As we navigate our own seasons of doubt and uncertainty, may we be encouraged by Thomas' story. Let us approach Jesus with our questions and uncertainties, knowing that He lovingly invites us to explore, to touch His wounds, and to encounter the reality of His resurrection. In that encounter, doubt can be transformed into unshakable faith, and we, like Thomas, can declare, "My Lord and my God!"





Soli Deo Gloria

Tuesday, May 04, 2021

Doubting Thomas





Many of us can identify with St. Thomas as the patron Saint of Doubt. We are constantly bombarded with situations where we have to decide to believe or disbelieve, to trust or distrust, facts or fiction, and so on and so forth. Yet over time the decisions we make mold us into becoming who we are today. When the disciples break the good news that Jesus is alive, Thomas is very clear about his terms of faith in the resurrection. Unless he sees and touches the scars on Jesus’ hands and side, he remains steadfast in his disbelief of the testimony of the disciples (John 20:24-25). We wonder where Thomas was when Jesus appeared to the disciples. Did Thomas stay away from the fellowship of the disciples because he is so brokenhearted from the betrayal, arrest, duplicitous trial and brutal death of Jesus? 

There are two notable incidents in the gospel of John where we see Thomas speaking passionately to Jesus and the disciples. The first time is when Jesus is called urgently to come to Judea to heal the dying Lazarus, however the Jews were all set to stone him if they crossed paths. Thomas, filled with love and loyalty to Jesus, courageously says he would go with Jesus to his death (John 11:7-16). The second time is at the last supper when Jesus reveals he is going away soon to the father saying, “You know the way to where I am going” (John 14:4-7). On hearing this revelation Thomas says, “Lord, we do not know where you are going. How can we know the way?” The impatient despair in Thomas’s frank question to Jesus is clear evidence that he doesn’t really understand who Jesus was or what he meant by this departing dialogue.


Is Thomas so brokenhearted that he just can’t get past the grief and doubts that overwhelm him? Or is it that he desperately longs to have the same personal experience that the other disciples had with the Lord? It is amazing that even after being with Jesus at the raising of Lazarus from the dead, he just does not understand that with God all things are possible (Matthew 19:26).

A week later Jesus comes back to visit his disciples and this time Thomas is with them. Jesus knows Thomas has doubts so he asks Thomas to touch and see that all his conditions for belief are met. Looking at Jesus with awe and reverence all he can say is, “My Lord and my God!” Jesus says to Thomas,”You believe because you have seen with your own eyes. Blessed are those who have not seen and yet have come to believe” (John 20:26-29). Jesus says we are blessed if we can believe in his resurrection without having seen him like his disciples.The gospel message that Jesus is the Christ, the son of the living God by whom we all receive eternal life can be found in the Bible. The sermons and parables of Jesus, along with the testimony, epistles and acts of the apostles are all we need to believe. Above all practicing the two commandments that are fundamental to our faith and witness as Christians is our love for God and our neighbor.


Don’t we all have our share of doubts and need for personal experiences? We have our own threshold for when we are willing to believe anyone or anything. Isn’t the opposite of doubt, faith? St. Anselm of Canterbury of the eleventh century is famous for his quote, “faith seeking understanding” (fides quaerens intellectum). What he means by that often misunderstood quote is, “an active love for God seeking a deeper knowledge of God.” To build our faith in Jesus, we have to first accept that God loves us and we in turn love him too. Just as St. Anselm’s love drove him to a deeper knowledge, we should use this as a model to grow our faith through this mutual bond of love with the Lord. As we face trials and tests in our lives that cause us to doubt, we learn to grow in faith by the confidence (hope) that God loves us and wants the best for us in our life. St. Paul says that to build our faith without love is really nothing of any value (1 Corinthians 13:2).


In the psalms we see that the Psalmists never question whether God exists but they lament crying out to God why they have been abandoned or their enemies have dominion over them. It is amusing that in St. Anselm’s book, Proslogion, he writes about the “Fool” who has said in his heart, “There is no God” (like the psalmist says Psalm 14:1). In this meditation he strives to reach the Christians who seek a rational basis for their faith in God. St. Anselm’s conclusion with so much of reverence and awe is, “A being than which none greater can be conceived must exist, and we call this being God.”


St. Paul says that God decides the measure of faith each one receives (Romans 12:3). For some faith is a God given gift. A key to faith is to humbly understand our identity in Christ. We judge ourselves conscientiously based on how God sees us and not as the world does. To some doubt is a normal phase in their spiritual lives, there is no need to be alarmed by those thoughts and feelings.  Michael Faraday the brilliant scientist who grew up in a good Christian home, became a believer much later in his life. He was a faithful member of a church from boyhood but passed through a sea of doubts until one day he came to humbly witness the reality of Christ in his life. It was his perseverance to seek God through his fellowship with other believers and share in their faith experiences that leads him to finally become a believer (Luke 11:5-12). When brilliant scientists like Faraday doubt yet still believe it gives us hope.


C. S. Lewis in his book “ Grief Observed ” writes about the pain of losing his wife when he doubted the goodness and fairness of God. He says, “My idea of God is not a divine idea. It has to be shattered from time to time. He shatters it himself. He is the great iconoclast. Could we not almost say that this shattering is one of the marks of his presence?” When spiritual giants like Lewis doubt yet still believe, it gives us hope. To Lewis, faith comes to us as a gift, the grace of the comforting presence of God reaching out and touching our shattered lives, when we confront significant downturns like death, disease, alcoholism, drug addiction, abuse, bankruptcy etc. Like the potter shapes and reshapes each piece to his delight, so God shapes us into masterpieces with his skill and creativity (Ephesians 2:10).


Jesus said to to Thomas,”You believe because you have seen with your own eyes. Blessed are those who have not seen and yet have come to believe” (John 20:26-29).  How do we believe in an invisible God? It is by being joyful in hope, patient in affliction, and faithful in prayer (Romans 12:12).  St Paul urges us to offer our lives as a living sacrifice to God and use our gifts to serve one another in love (Romans 12:1-2, 6-8). We are bound to face trials and turbulences in our lives. Can we climb half way up a mountain and then give up? If we do reach heights that seem unscalable in life, with the help of the Holy Spirit we persist in prayer like the parable of the persistent widow until we find our way again (Luke 18:1-8). There will be times we lament with all our heart to God like the Psalmist until we are comforted by the presence of God in our lives (Psalm 55:17). The important act of faith is to pray fervently and not let our problems and pain fester within us. When we articulate our doubts to a caring prayer fellowship group it helps to clean up the toxicity in our lives. The path to spiritual maturity is through childlike humility of learning to trust in the path God has carved out for us to walk through (Matthew 18:1-4). A critical step in prayer is when we surrender our doubts to a loving God and ask him to help us understand with the help of the Holy Spirit enlightening us with God’s Word. We stand on the promises that God the author and perfecter of our faith will mold us to be perfect one day. (Hebrews 12:2; Romans 8:29-30; Philippians 1:6). 


Prayer: - Lord Jesus, your living presence in the lives of Thomas and the other disciples drew them with chords of love to believe in your resurrection. Oh Lord shine in our hearts the light of your glory that we may grow in faith, hope and love to believe in you as our Savior and Lord. Amen




Soli Deo Gloria

Tuesday, March 01, 2011

In the Footsteps of St. Thomas

A Historical Odyssey of the Mar Thoma Church


Nestled in the rich tapestry of India's religious landscape lies the Mar Thoma Church, a vibrant and dynamic Christian denomination with a history spanning over centuries. From its humble beginnings to its present-day global outreach, the Mar Thoma Church has undergone a remarkable journey of faith, resilience, and growth. In this blog, we embark on a journey through time to explore the intriguing history, transformative reformation, and enduring legacy of the Mar Thoma Church. The term "Mar Thoma" has its origins in Syriac, a dialect of Aramaic, which was the language spoken by Jesus and his disciples. In Syriac, "Mar" is an honorific title meaning "Saint," and "Thoma" is the Syriac equivalent of the name "Thomas." Therefore, "Mar Thoma" translates to "Saint Thomas."

Pre-Reformation Era: The origins of the Mar Thoma Church trace back to the arrival of St. Thomas, the Apostle of Jesus Christ, on the shores of India in AD 52. St. Thomas's missionary zeal led him to establish Christian communities along the Malabar Coast, laying the foundation for what would become one of India's oldest Christian traditions. Tradition has it that St. Thomas organized seven Christian communities, each contributing to the rich tapestry of the nascent Christian faith in India. These communities, including Cranganore, Niranam, and Quilon, served as beacons of light amidst the diverse cultural landscape of ancient India.

Reformation Movement: Fast forward to the 19th century, and the Mar Thoma Church found itself at a crossroads. Inspired by the ideals of the Protestant Reformation and the teachings of the New Testament, visionary leaders like Palakunnathu Abraham Malpan and Kaithayil Geevarghese Malpan embarked on a journey of spiritual renewal and reform. Their efforts aimed to restore the purity of the early Church, emphasizing salvation by faith in Jesus Christ, the priesthood of all believers, and the primacy of the Word of God.

The Reformation movement faced resistance from within the Church hierarchy, leading to a split and subsequent legal battles. However, the reformists remained steadfast in their convictions, eventually leading to the establishment of an independent Mar Thoma Church under the leadership of Mathews Mar Athanasius. Despite facing challenges and setbacks, the reformists' unwavering faith and commitment to biblical principles laid the groundwork for a revitalized and spiritually vibrant community.

Post-Reformation Era: The aftermath of the Reformation saw the Mar Thoma Church emerge as a resilient and forward-looking institution. Despite the loss of material possessions and legal battles, the Church experienced exponential growth and expansion, both within India and beyond. Today, the Mar Thoma Church boasts a global presence, with parishes and congregations spanning continents and a diverse community united by a shared faith and heritage.

The Church's commitment to education, social welfare, and ecumenical engagement underscores its holistic approach to ministry and mission. From schools and colleges to hospitals and social welfare institutions, the Mar Thoma Church continues to make a meaningful impact on society, guided by the principles of love, compassion, and service.

As we reflect on the rich history and enduring legacy of the Mar Thoma Church, we are reminded of its remarkable journey of faith, resilience, and transformation. From its humble beginnings to its present-day global outreach, the Mar Thoma Church stands as a testament to the enduring power of the Gospel and the unwavering commitment of its members. As we look to the future, may the Mar Thoma Church continue to shine as a beacon of hope, love, and reconciliation in a world in need of healing and redemption.






Soli Deo Gloria

Monday, February 28, 2011

The St. Thomas Christians of India





The St. Thomas Christians, also known as Nasranis (Followers of The Nazarene), are an ancient Christian community in India whose tradition traces its origin to the Apostle Thomas. According to tradition, St. Thomas arrived in the southwestern coast of India in the 1st century AD and evangelized in various regions. The St. Thomas Christians have a rich history, unique traditions, and a distinct form of Christianity within the broader Indian context. Here are some key aspects of their faith:

  1. Apostolic Connection: St. Thomas Christians claim a direct apostolic connection to St. Thomas, affirming that he established Christian communities in India. This tradition is foundational to their identity and is reflected in the name "St. Thomas Christians."

  2. Liturgical Heritage: St. Thomas Christians have a distinctive liturgical heritage that combines elements of Eastern Christianity with indigenous Indian customs. They follow various liturgical traditions, including the East Syriac Rite and West Syriac Rite, and use Syriac, Malayalam, and other languages in their worship.

  3. Syriac Influence: The Syriac Christian influence on St. Thomas Christians is notable, and Syriac remains an important liturgical and cultural language for them. The use of Syriac in their worship distinguishes them from other Christian communities in India.

  4. Ecclesiastical Independence: Historically, the St. Thomas Christians were connected to the Church of the East but gradually developed their ecclesiastical structures. Over time, divisions and affiliations with different Christian denominations occurred, leading to the existence of various St. Thomas Christian denominations today, including the Syro-Malabar Catholic Church and the Malankara Orthodox Syrian Church.

  5. Cultural Integration: St. Thomas Christians have integrated Indian cultural elements into their Christian practices. This fusion is evident in their art, architecture, and celebrations. The blending of Indian traditions with Christianity has resulted in a unique cultural expression.

  6. Religious Tolerance: The history of St. Thomas Christians includes interactions with various religious communities in India. Their traditions reflect a degree of religious tolerance and accommodation, allowing for a distinctive coexistence with the diverse religious landscape of India.

  7. Contributions to Christianity in India: St. Thomas Christians have made significant contributions to the growth of Christianity in India. They played a role in early evangelization and continue to contribute to theological, educational, and social aspects of Indian Christianity.

While the St. Thomas Christian community is diverse with various denominations and traditions, their shared heritage and apostolic origin continue to shape their faith and identity in the context of India's religious and cultural diversity.




Soli Deo Gloria

Friday, February 11, 2011

🌊 The Expanding Story of the St. Thomas Christians



Links Beyond the Seas


From Alexandria to Persia — the early bridges of faith that connected the Indian Church to the wider world.


Pantaenus of Alexandria — A Missionary from the West


By the end of the second century, the Christian community in South India — founded, as tradition holds, by St. Thomas the Apostle — lived quietly along the Malabar Coast. They prayed, worshiped, and worked the land, preserving in their hearts the memory of the Apostle who once walked their shores. For nearly a hundred and fifty years after his martyrdom, this small but steadfast church seemed cut off from the outside world.

Then, around A.D. 189, a remarkable event bridged that silence. Pantaenus, a philosopher, theologian, and missionary from the great Catechetical School of Alexandria in Egypt, journeyed east “to preach Christ to the Indians.”  His visit is recorded by Eusebius of Caesarea in his Ecclesiastical History (Book V, Ch. 10), who notes that Pantaenus found a community of believers who “had already known Christ” and possessed a copy of the Gospel according to Matthew written in Hebrew — said to have been left behind by St. Bartholomew or St. Thomas.

Whether taken literally or symbolically, this meeting marks the first recorded contact between the ancient Church of Malabar and the wider Christian world.  It revealed to Alexandria — and through it, to Christendom — that faith in Christ had taken root far beyond the Roman Empire, flourishing in a distant land where the Apostle Thomas had once proclaimed the Gospel.  Through Pantaenus, the quiet faith of Kerala reached the ears of the Mediterranean Church, showing that Christianity’s heart was already global — a light shining from East to West.


The First Persian Immigration — Thomas of Cana


A few centuries later, new waves of connection arrived — this time from the East.  Around the fourth century, a Christian merchant named Thomas of Cana (Knai Thomman) came from Persia or Mesopotamia to the Malabar Coast.  With him traveled a group of families, clergy, and artisans from the Church of the East, seeking trade, settlement, and fellowship with the Christians of India.

According to local tradition, the Kerala ruler Cheraman Perumal received Thomas and his followers with honor and granted them land and privileges at Cranganore (Muziris).  A copper plate charter, preserved in later copies, records these rights — including the freedom to build churches, ring bells, and live according to their customs.

This event marks the first Persian immigration, linking the St. Thomas Christians more closely to the East Syrian Church centered in Edessa and Seleucia-Ctesiphon.  These new arrivals brought with them Syriac liturgical books, clergy, and theological learning.  They strengthened the faith of a people who had preserved the Gospel through centuries of isolation and gave them renewed ties to the great Christian centers of the East.


The Second Persian Immigration — Mar Sabrisho and Mar Peruz


By the ninth century, another group of immigrants arrived from Persia — this time led by Mar Sabrisho (also known as Marwan Sabriso) and Mar Peruz, bishops of the Church of the East.  They came seeking refuge from persecution and carried with them relics, manuscripts, and sacred vessels.

They were warmly received by the ruler of Venad, who granted them land at Quilon (Kollam), a flourishing port city.  There they founded the Tharisapalli Church in A.D. 825, and their privileges were inscribed on the famous Tharisapalli Copper Plates, written in both old Malayalam and Pahlavi (Middle Persian). These grants guaranteed protection, trade rights, and self-governance — remarkable evidence of the Church’s peaceful coexistence with local rulers.

The arrival of these Persian Christians brought renewed vitality to the Indian Church.  They introduced scholars, teachers, and liturgical treasures that strengthened both the spiritual and cultural life of the St. Thomas community.  Through them, the Indian Church remained in communion with the Eastern patriarchates — a bridge stretching from Kerala to Mesopotamia, from Kollam to Ctesiphon.


A Church Connected Yet Distinct


These two immigrations — along with the earlier visit of Pantaenus — show that the Indian Church was never an isolated relic, but an integral part of the worldwide body of Christ.  It maintained independence in practice and identity, yet remained connected through faith, prayer, and fellowship.

Long before European missionaries set sail, there already existed on the Malabar coast a vibrant Christian community — deeply Indian, profoundly Eastern, and unmistakably apostolic.  Their churches faced east toward Jerusalem; their prayers were sung in Syriac; their customs reflected both Semitic and Indian culture.  And their heart — shaped by centuries of faith — remained loyal to the words first preached by the Apostle Thomas.


Reflection


When Pantaenus came from Alexandria, he found not strangers but brethren in Christ.  When Thomas of Cana and Mar Sabrisho came from Persia, they did not bring a new religion but renewed fellowship.  Together, these encounters reveal a Church whose story was not of conquest but of continuity, not of domination but of devotion.

This is the legacy of the St. Thomas Christians — a community born of the Apostle’s faith, nurtured by the East, and sustained by God’s providence through centuries of change.  Their history reminds us that the Church is truly “catholic” — universal, bound not by empire or language, but by the love of Christ that crosses every sea.


🪔 Prayer


O Lord Jesus Christ,

who called Your Apostle Thomas to bear witness in our land,

we thank You for the faith that took root upon our shores.


Bless the Church that still bears his name.

As You sent teachers like Pantaenus from the West

and faithful pilgrims from Persia in the East,

so send us, Lord, to renew Your light in our generation.


May we be a Church both ancient and alive,

rooted in Scripture, radiant in service,

and united in Your love that knows no borders.


Kyrie Eleison — Κύριε ἐλέησον — 

Lord, have mercy upon us.

Maran esrahm alain — ܡܪܢ ܐܣܪܚܡ ܥܠܝܢ — 

Lord, have mercy upon us.

 

Amen.




📜 Historical Evidence for the Early Global Links of the St. Thomas Christians


1. The Visit of Pantaenus (c. A.D. 189)

  • Primary Source: Eusebius of Caesarea, Ecclesiastical History, Book V, Ch. 10.

     
    “Pantaenus was sent to India, where it is reported that he found some who had already known Christ. They possessed the Gospel according to Matthew in Hebrew, which had been left there by the Apostle Bartholomew.”

     — Eusebius, Hist. Eccl., V.10 (A.D. 324)

  • Clement of Alexandria (Pantaenus’s student) indirectly confirms his teacher’s missionary zeal and the Alexandrian school’s global outlook.

    • Stromata, I.1, VII.106: mentions Pantaenus as “the Sicilian bee who fed many with the honey of the Scriptures.”

  • Scholarly References:

    • Stephen Neill, A History of Christianity in India: The Beginnings to AD 1707 (Cambridge University Press, 1984), pp. 26–28.

    • A.E. Medlycott, India and the Apostle Thomas (London, 1905), pp. 90–95.

    • H. G. Rawlinson, Intercourse Between India and the Western World (Cambridge, 1926), pp. 131–133.

Summary: These sources confirm that by the late 2nd century, there existed an established Christian community in India, known to the Church of Alexandria.


2. The First Persian Immigration — Thomas of Cana (Knai Thomman)

  • Local Tradition: Recorded in The Acts of the Thomas Christians (Portuguese MSS, 17th century, based on earlier Syriac sources) and in the Ramban Pattu (Syriac-Malayalam ballads).

  • Copper Plate Grants: Although the original plates are lost, copies survive in the Cochin Archives and the British Museum — traditionally dated to the 4th or 5th century, granting land and privileges to the followers of Thomas of Cana at Cranganore.

  • Cultural Evidence: The community known as Knānāya Christians (from Knāy, meaning “merchant”) still trace their ancestry to this migration. Their social customs and endogamous practices preserve elements of Syriac and Persian Christian identity.

  • Scholarly References:

    • G. T. Mackenzie, Christianity in Travancore (London, 1901), pp. 42–48.

    • A. Mingana, “The Early Spread of Christianity in India,” Bulletin of the John Rylands Library 10 (1926): 435–514.

    • A. E. Medlycott, India and the Apostle Thomas, pp. 200–210.

    • Placid J. Podipara, The Thomas Christians (1958), pp. 65–72.

Summary: The Thomas of Cana episode demonstrates continuing contact between the Malabar Christians and the Persian Church (Church of the East), bringing renewed clergy and trade connections.


3. The Second Persian Immigration — Mar Sabrisho (Marwan Sabriso) and Mar Peruz (A.D. 823–825)

  • Primary Evidence: The Tharisapalli Copper Plates (A.D. 825).

     These are the earliest surviving Christian documents in India.

    • Issued by Ayyan Adikal Thiruvatikal, ruler of Venad (Travancore).

    • Written in Vattezhuthu-Tamil and Pahlavi (Middle Persian).

    • Preserved today in the Syrian Orthodox Seminary, Kottayam, and studied extensively by historians and epigraphists.

    • They record royal grants to Mar Sabrisho and his followers for the establishment of a trading settlement and church at Tharisapalli, Quilon (Kollam).

  • Primary Sources:

    • Epigraphia Indica (Vol. 4, 1896): translation and commentary by V. Venkayya.

    • Travancore Archaeological Series (Vol. 2, 1910): full text and analysis.

    • “The Kollam Plates of Sthanu Ravi,” Indian Antiquary, Vol. 23 (1894).

  • Scholarly References:

    • G. T. Mackenzie, Christianity in Travancore, pp. 50–54.

    • Stephen Neill, A History of Christianity in India, pp. 33–37.

    • K. M. Panikkar, Malabar and the Portuguese (1929), pp. 12–14.

Summary: These Persian Christians from the Church of the East revitalized the Malabar Church, deepening its liturgical and theological connections with Mesopotamia. The Tharisapalli Plates remain tangible proof of an officially recognized Christian presence in 9th-century Kerala.

4. Broader Context — Links with the Church of the East

  • The Indian Church remained under the Patriarch of Seleucia-Ctesiphon (modern Iraq) until the 16th century, as attested by several surviving letters:

    • Letter of Patriarch Isho’yabh III to the Christians in India (c. A.D. 650).

    • Letter of Patriarch Timothy I (A.D. 780–823), mentioning bishops appointed to India.

    • Synod of Diamper records (A.D. 1599) that the Indian Church had long received bishops “from Babylon and Persia.”

  • References:

    • W. Wright, A Short History of Syriac Literature (London, 1894), pp. 7–10.

    • J. M. Fiey, Christians in Iraq (1970).

    • George Menachery, The St. Thomas Christian Encyclopedia of India, Vol. I (1973).


🕊️ Summary Insight

The story of Pantaenus, Thomas of Cana, and Mar Sabrisho is not a series of disconnected legends but part of a continuous history of cross-cultural Christian exchange.

From the Alexandrian School of Egypt to the Syriac Church of Persia, and from Quilon’s copper plates to the liturgies still sung in Kerala today, the evidence shows an ancient, independent Indian Church deeply rooted in apostolic tradition yet vibrantly connected to the world — centuries before Western missions began.




Soli Deo Gloria

Not Consumed

From “Who Am I?” to the Great “I AM”   Verse by Verse study of Genesis 3:1-15 Exodus 3 begins in an ordinary place. Moses is not in Pharao...